Here goes another one... maybe a bit more VST-related.
Hopefully...
Maybe?
I was reading over a thread on TrekWeb last week about the future of Trek - a popular topic these days - and i began to compare VST's shows to some of the ideas being thrown around. How would each VST series fare if the execs at Paramount suddenly decided to produce it as the next Trek series or movie?
I'll start with the original - Renaissance. The first thing you have to understand about REN is that it's quite a bit darker than anything Trek has done before - yes, even DS9. That would be the biggest thing for audiences to adapt to - audiences unfamiliar with VST anyway - but given the state of most live-action drama's these days, that darkness could help draw in more viewers. At the same time though, there are many hardcore Trek fans who dislike that take on Gene Roddenberry's universe. These same people disliked DS9, and are the TOS-core types, still, there are a growing number of TOS fans who are beginning to get more and more into DS9-style Trek.
REN's character-driven approach to Trek - perhaps more than any other Trek series, virtual or otherwise - would give audiences a new take on Trek, especially those who weren't DS9 fans. That works both ways, though as REN is heavily based on the events of DS9. Because of that, it would likely appeal more to the DS9 fans than anyone else. Still, the quality stories and great characters would likely make REN a hit with casual audiences as well. By that i mean the 24 fans out there, the Lost faithful, and the 4400 fanatics (myself included). The biggest question is how the hardcore TOS fans would react to REN's gritty, DS9-style approach to the franchise.
Next up, Frontiers. It's been said that Frontiers is "Star Trek in its purest form" and i think that's true. The concept of Frontiers is the one i could most see making it to the small screen. The tech geeks out there would have plenty of new tech gadgets to geek-out about, but Frontiers has never really been about technobabble at its core - it's more a mix of that old TOS exploration, mixed with TNG's science and family atmosphere between its characters, with a pinch of DS9's political drama thrown in for good measure. That's why it would likely have the best shot at success - it's got a little of everything, and a little something for everyone.
The TOS faithful would love Frontiers concept of actually EXPLORING, and exploring NEW galaxies, rather than the same old Milky Way we're used to. The DS9 fans would get their character drama and political intrigue, and the TNG buffs would get their science & technology. Don't get me wrong though - I'm not saying Frontiers is a better series than any of the others - in fact, i happen to think Renaissance is the best Trek fan fic ever written, script-based or otherwise. Frontiers would however, make the most logical choice as an actual live-action series.
Star's End takes the concept of DS9 one step further. Instead of being set on a space station, it's set planet-side. This would likely be too radical a change for the hardcore audience who never even gave DS9 a chance because they weren't moving. Still, SE provides great character drama, and some of the most innovative stories you'll see in a Trek setting. It could build its own audience, but there would likely be the same type of rift as when DS9 first launched. I certainly wouldn't mind seeing it produced, though.
Avalon... what can i say about Avalon. The first Trek series to be given a TV-MA rating no doubt. Maybe aired late-night, or edited for content, which would make room for uncensored DVD releases. Seriously though, Avalon's attitude is quite refreshing to me. It doesn't take itself too seriously, but it's very much a fan fiction series when it comes to the language and such - not to mention a certain... Scene. If Avalon were to ever make it to TV, it would have to be so cleaned up, and be changed so much there would be little point of even trying. It's really better suited to the internet, where it can be as creatively free as it wants to be - and needs to be. Otherwise, it just wouldn't be Avalon.
Knight's Haven I'm not sure about since i know next to nothing about the series until it launches. Maybe I'll discuss it later.
The 4400 this week was amazing. I'm beginning to think that, not only is this the best show currently on television, but maybe one of the best shows in the last decade. If you haven't checked it out yet, you're cheating yourself.
The Dead Zone, on the other hand, has disappointed two weeks in a row. It's really apparent how much the tragic death of Michael Piller has affected the creative process behind the scenes with the show. The man really was brilliant when it came to storytelling.
Once again, i continue my crusade to convert everyone on VST to an Ultimate Spider-Man reader: my sample's still up at
http://home.ec.rr.com/nx84/usm.html - contact me if you want the first 96 issues - they're FREE (if not entirely legal).
Marvel announced this week that they're going to do a live-action Avengers movie, largely based on the Ultimate universe version of the group - The Ultimates. This could be good... very good. Then again, they could really screw it up!
The Frontiers movie trailer is very nearly complete. Be prepared to be blown away...
The Carolina Panthers played their first preseason game of the 2006 season Saturday night against the Buffalo Bills, and wouldn't you know it - the local FOX affiliate had "technical difficulties" connecting to the satellite feed, causing everyone in the area to miss the game. I was forced to listen on the radio - bad reception and all, and as you can imagine was just a little bit pissed off.
Anyway... the Panthers won the game 14-13.